Small changes, big impact – here’s what’s sabotaging your expensive look
You know that feeling when you put together an outfit that looks perfect in your mirror, but then you see a photo and something just feels… off? Not quite as polished as you imagined? Here’s the thing: looking expensive has way less to do with how much you spent and way more to do with the small details most people completely overlook.
I’ve made every single one of these mistakes (some of them embarrassingly recently), and fixing them has been a complete game-changer. The best part? These aren’t about buying new clothes or spending more money. They’re about styling smarter with what you already have.
Let’s talk about the five styling mistakes that are making your outfits look cheaper than they are – and exactly how to fix them.
This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps keep Lush Finds running! Read my full Affiliate Disclosure.
Mistake #1: Wearing Clothes That Don’t Fit Properly
This is the biggest one, and honestly, it’s the mistake that ruins more outfits than anything else. You can wear a $500 designer piece, but if it doesn’t fit right, it’ll look worse than a $20 item that fits perfectly.
What this looks like:
- Pants that bunch at the ankles
- Sleeves that go past your knuckles
- Shoulder seams that fall down your arms
- Shirts that strain across the chest or gap between buttons
- Waistbands that create muffin top (not because of your body, but because of wrong sizing)
- Blazers with shoulders that are too wide or too narrow
Why it makes you look cheap: Ill-fitting clothes give the impression that you grabbed something off the rack without trying it on, or that you’re wearing someone else’s clothes. It looks careless and unintentional, which reads as “I don’t really care about my appearance” even when you do.
How to fix it:
The immediate fix: Find a good tailor. Seriously, this is life-changing. Getting your pants hemmed, your sleeves shortened, or your waist taken in typically costs $10-30 per item. That $25 pair of pants with a $15 hem will look more expensive than $100 pants that drag on the floor.
The shopping fix: When buying new clothes, prioritize fit over everything else. If something fits perfectly in the shoulders and chest but is too long in the sleeves or legs, buy it anyway and get it tailored. But if something doesn’t fit in the shoulders or through the bust – pass on it. Those alterations are expensive and often impossible.
The styling fix:
- Pants too long? Cuff them intentionally with a clean roll, or tuck them into boots
- Sleeves too long? Push them up to 3/4 length for a casual look
- Shirt too loose? Do a front tuck or side tuck to define your waist
- Dress too big? Add a belt to create shape
Mistake #2: Ignoring Fabric Quality and Care
The fastest way to make an outfit look cheap? Wear wrinkled, pilled, or faded fabrics. It doesn’t matter if your dress cost $200 – if it’s covered in pills and wrinkles, it looks like you found it crumpled at the bottom of your laundry basket.
What this looks like:
- Visible pilling on sweaters, leggings, or knits
- Wrinkled cotton shirts or linen pieces
- Faded black clothes that look gray
- Shiny, cheap-looking polyester that catches light weird
- Stretched-out fabrics that have lost their shape
Why it makes you look cheap: Worn-out or poorly maintained fabrics signal that either your clothes are low quality, or you don’t take care of them. Either way, it undermines the entire outfit. Even luxury brands look terrible when they’re pilled and wrinkled.
How to fix it:
The fabric choice fix: When shopping, feel everything before you buy it. Avoid anything that:
- Feels too thin (you can see through it in natural light)
- Has an overly synthetic, plastic-y texture
- Is so lightweight it’ll wrinkle just by looking at it
- Already has that cheap sheen before you even buy it
Instead, look for:
- Cotton and cotton blends
- Structured knits with some weight to them
- Matte finishes instead of shiny ones
- Fabrics with a nice drape (they should fall smoothly when you hold them up)
The care fix:
- Invest in a fabric shaver ($10-15) – removes pills in seconds and makes old clothes look new
- Steam or iron before wearing – yes, it’s annoying, but it makes a huge difference
- Use fabric refresher spray – for items you can’t wash frequently
- Wash clothes inside out – prevents fading and reduces pilling
- Follow care instructions – actually read those tags
The emergency fix: Heading out and notice wrinkles? Hang the item in your bathroom while you shower – the steam helps. Or use a hair straightener on collars and cuffs in a pinch.
Mistake #3: Over-Accessorizing or Under-Accessorizing
There’s a sweet spot with accessories, and most of us either go way overboard or completely forget about them. Both extremes make an outfit look less polished.
What this looks like:
Over-accessorizing:
- Wearing every piece of jewelry you own at once
- Mixing too many colors or styles that compete with each other
- Statement necklace + statement earrings + statement bracelet + statement bag
- So much jewelry that it’s all people notice
Under-accessorizing:
- Plain outfit with zero accessories (not minimal – just incomplete)
- Forgetting to wear a watch or jewelry when an outfit needs finishing
- Carrying a worn-out bag that ruins an otherwise nice outfit
- Missing that one piece that would tie everything together
Why it makes you look cheap: Over-accessorizing looks costume-y and tries too hard. Under-accessorizing looks unfinished, like you got dressed halfway and gave up. Both signal that you don’t quite know how to pull an outfit together.
How to fix it:
The rule of three: Pick three accessory categories maximum. For example:
- Earrings + watch + bag
- Necklace + bracelet + shoes (if they’re statement shoes)
- Scarf + earrings + belt
The one-statement rule: If you’re wearing a statement piece (bold necklace, colorful bag, dramatic earrings), keep everything else simple and subtle. One star of the show is enough.
The classic formula:
- Small stud or hoop earrings (always safe)
- A simple necklace OR a scarf (not both)
- One bracelet or watch
- A structured bag that matches your outfit’s vibe
For minimal/modern looks:
- One or two delicate pieces of jewelry
- A quality watch
- Clean, simple bag
- Let the outfit be the focus
The lazy girl hack: Pick a jewelry “uniform” and wear it every day. Mine is small gold hoops + a simple necklace + my watch. Takes zero thought and always looks polished.
Mistake #4: Wearing the Wrong Shoes for the Outfit
Your shoes can make or break an outfit faster than any other single piece. The wrong shoes will drag down even the most expensive outfit, while the right shoes elevate a basic look instantly.
What this looks like:
- Dirty, scuffed, or worn-out shoes with a nice outfit
- Athletic shoes with non-athletic outfits (unless intentionally styled)
- Shoes that are the wrong formality level (too casual or too dressy)
- Shoes that clash with the outfit’s style or color palette
- Uncomfortable shoes that make you walk weird (yes, people notice)
Why it makes you look cheap: Shoes are one of the first things people notice, even subconsciously. Beat-up or mismatched shoes suggest you either don’t have better options or don’t care enough to choose appropriately. Plus, if you’re uncomfortable, you won’t carry yourself confidently.
How to fix it:
The essential shoe wardrobe: You don’t need 50 pairs. You need these basics in good condition:
- Clean white sneakers (surprisingly versatile)
- Black ankle boots (work with everything)
- Nude or black flats
- One pair of comfortable heels or loafers for dressier occasions
The matching rule: Your shoes should either:
- Match another element in your outfit (like your bag or belt)
- Be neutral enough to go with anything (black, nude, white, tan)
- Intentionally contrast in a stylish way (but this is advanced level)
The condition check:
- Weekly: Wipe down shoes and check for scuffs
- Monthly: Clean thoroughly and condition leather
- Replace when: Heels are worn down, soles are separating, or stains won’t come out
The styling guidelines:
- Casual outfits: Sneakers, flat sandals, ankle boots
- Business casual: Loafers, pointed flats, low block heels, clean boots
- Dressy occasions: Heels, dressy flats, heeled boots
- Weekend errands: Clean sneakers or casual boots (not your beaters)
Pro tip: If your shoes are uncomfortable, you won’t look good. Period. You’ll fidget, your posture will suffer, and you’ll radiate discomfort. Invest in shoes that you can actually wear for more than 30 minutes.
Mistake #5: Ignoring Color Coordination and Undertones
This is the subtle mistake that most people don’t even realize they’re making. You can be wearing expensive, well-fitting clothes in perfect condition, but if the colors clash or don’t suit your undertones, something will feel off.
What this looks like:
- Wearing colors that make your skin look washed out or sallow
- Mixing warm and cool tones in a chaotic way
- Too many competing colors in one outfit
- Black and navy together (controversial, but usually doesn’t work)
- Colors that clash with your natural coloring
Why it makes you look cheap: Poor color choices make you look like you got dressed in the dark or grabbed random pieces without thinking. It lacks intentionality and sophistication. Even worse, wearing colors that don’t suit your undertones can make you look tired or unhealthy.
How to fix it:
Find your undertones:
- Warm undertones: Gold jewelry looks better on you, cream suits you better than stark white, warm colors (coral, peach, warm reds, olive green) make you glow
- Cool undertones: Silver jewelry looks better, true white suits you, cool colors (royal blue, emerald, true red, purple) are your friends
- Neutral undertones: Lucky you – most colors work
Quick test: Look at the veins on your wrist:
- Green veins = warm undertones
- Blue/purple veins = cool undertones
- Can’t tell/both = neutral
The easy color formulas:
Monochrome magic: Wear different shades of the same color. Looks instantly expensive and put-together. Examples:
- All black (classic)
- Cream sweater + beige pants + tan bag
- Navy blazer + light blue shirt + dark blue jeans
Neutral + one color: Build around neutrals (black, white, gray, beige, navy) and add one accent color. Examples:
- Black pants + white shirt + red bag
- Gray sweater + black pants + burgundy shoes
- Beige coat + jeans + emerald scarf
Complementary pairs: Stick to two colors maximum that complement each other:
- Black + white (timeless)
- Navy + white
- Camel + black
- Gray + blush pink
- Denim + cream
What to avoid:
- More than three colors in one outfit
- Mixing black and brown (unless you really know what you’re doing)
- Neon or overly bright colors in large doses (small accessories are fine)
- Colors that make you look tired (you’ll know – trust your gut)
The lazy solution: Build a capsule wardrobe around 2-3 neutral colors. Then everything matches automatically, and you always look coordinated.
The Overall Theme: Intentionality Makes You Look Expensive
Notice a pattern? All five of these mistakes come down to one thing: looking like you didn’t put thought into your outfit. When your clothes fit well, look cared for, are properly accessorized, include appropriate shoes, and feature coordinated colors, you look intentional. And intentional always looks expensive.
The good news? None of this requires spending more money. It’s about:
- Taking care of what you have
- Making smart choices when shopping
- Paying attention to the details
- Building outfits thoughtfully instead of randomly
Your Action Plan
Pick ONE of these mistakes to focus on this week. Don’t try to fix everything at once – that’s overwhelming and you’ll give up.
Start here:
- Go through your closet and identify which mistake you make most often
- Fix one outfit using the guidelines above
- Notice how much better you feel when that detail is handled
- Move on to the next mistake once the first one becomes a habit
Looking expensive isn’t about having money – it’s about looking like you care. And that’s completely free.
Now, which of these mistakes are you most guilty of? (I’m currently working on the shoe thing – my comfy flats are… well, they’ve seen better days.)
This post contains affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you purchase through my links at no extra cost to you. I only recommend products and advice I genuinely believe will help you look and feel your best!
